Vocal Pedagogy; an additive or a subtractive art?

Gravestone Twins

Evan Bortnick   http://musa-vocalis.de/

Gesangsunterricht Wiesbaden

The way you answer this question is the way you teach. I’ve argued for both sides of the question, depends who’s asking. On the one hand it often feels like the voice lesson mainly consists in evoking natural functions, eliminating the accumulated helping tensions (which are no longer ‘helping’), thus allowing the organic instincts of the singer to come to the fore. On the other hand a voice lesson at times feels like I am ‘conditioning’ the student to establish healthy habits which no amount of ‘instinct’ could, by itself, ever bring forth.

I have a good singer friend who maintains that singing (especially opera) is at core unnatural. In some ways she’s right. Doing what we do for hours at a time in rehearsal and performance has no parallel in most definitions of ‘natural’. Still, I often think that even if it is unnatural in that sense, it docks on natural processes, if you’re willing to include the more dramatic emotional expressions ‘natural’. I’m speaking here of processes which are mostly of relatively short duration: spontaneous, hearty laughter, whole body authentic rhythmic weeping, vomiting, making yourself heard over a noisy crowd, spontaneous shouts of warning, Kiais of aggression, military tones of command, cries for help over great distances….like that. I believe we are ‘naturally selected’ to do this especially well for some very good evolutionary reasons.  How much of this is learned behavior and how much is instinct and evocable?

I heard a story once which is appropriate here. Someone once asked Michelangelo how he approached sculpture. His reply was that he simply removed everything from the marble that didn’t need to be there! There is something valuable here for speakers, for singers and for teachers. Assuming a ‘normal’ physical and mental development (a large assumption, I know!), the ‘functions’ of the voice all have a natural context. When we turn the light of consciousness on them and repeat them, the ensuing training effect could make this seem unnatural. As unnatural perhaps as a full twisting double layout salto?….or running an ultra-marathon?….or static apnea for 10 minutes? All these examples and so many more are examples of natural functions, trained and executed to perfection.

One of the etymological roots of the word EDUCATION comes from the Latin educere, ‘to lead out from’. In one sense, this is always true. In another it isn’t. In questions of style and tradition, for example, there is little or no ‘leading out from…’. Knowing Verdi’s birthday cannot be evoked by an internal function, to use an obvious example. Making a cognitive distinction between Legato and Larghetto on the verbal level is also conditioned learning. A physical, sensory understanding of the same distinction, however, IS education in the etymological sense. So in its essence the word refers to that which Michelangelo is evoking; strip away the non-essentials, as evidenced BY THE STUDENT (as opposed to the teacher’s ideas of ‘method’) and growth, learning and advancement will proceed in its time.

Evan Bortnick   http://musa-vocalis.de/

Gesangsunterricht Wiesbaden


About evanb54

I'm a passionate, curious learning junkie--- an X-Opera Singer turned Voice Teacher, Voice Teachers Teacher, NLP Lehrtrainer, Off-Path Coach, Cranio-Sacral worker and a few other even less mainstream things. Everything I've learned or taught revolves around THE VOICE. The Voice as a tool of artistic expression. The Voice as a tool of emotional transparency. The voice as a tool of flexible communication. If you're interested in voice lessons or vocal pedagogy, please visit this site: https://www.musa-vocalis.de/ There's an English and a German version. If you're interested in voice coaching, public speaking, trainer skills or presentation skills, please visit me here: https://www.vocalimpactpotential.de/ ..and feel free to send any questions. Looking forward to hearing from you! More information can be found at my Institute Site: www.musa-vocalis.de The Wiesbaden Academy of the Vocal Muse Gesangsunterricht Wiesbaden, Coaching, Voice Pedagogy
This entry was posted in Art, Authenticity, Class, Congruence, Emotional Intelligence, Mind-Body, Music, Opera, Pedagogy, Performance, Singing, Teaching, Voice and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Vocal Pedagogy; an additive or a subtractive art?

  1. I side with Michelangelo: strip away the non-essentials. Lots of physical/mental things we do are “unnatural”, like playing basketball, baseball, football, golf, etc. But building on natural processes like targeted throwing, walking and running, we gradually train the specific skills for the activities mentioned.

    Meditation breathing is not”natural”. It was discovered by yogis 3,000 years ago, and it has thew power to induce deep physical and mental calm, lowering blood pressure, and canceling the toxic chemicals triggered by the “fight-or-flight” response ( an involuntary sympathetic nervous system response) by causing the parasympathetic nervous to kick in. This “meditation breathing” is absolutely basic to healthy, comfortable (legit or operatic) singing. Without this “cushion” of support, singers would quickly tear their vocal folds to pieces, damaging their voices irreparably.

    No singer (and probably no stage actor) literally “feels” the emotional states they portray onstage in the way they WOULD feel them in real life. Stage action is an imaginative SIMULATION of the observable behavior resulting from real-life emotional experience. A singer who actually FELT the emotions simulated would immediately wreck the necessary calm balance necessary for the demands of singing. The technique INDISPENSABLE to singing is comparable to the exquisitely fine balance control of a circus tightrope walker.

    Singing technique can ONLY be mastered in the act of singing. This is because singing is a whole-person EXPERIENCE, not a THING, and not a mere propositional CONCEPT. Attempts to reify or mechanize singing technique will ALWAYS fail.

  2. It’s actually a nice and useful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s